Stanley's New Halloween Tumblers are Selling Out

You can still find them at Dick's Sporting Goods

Stanley Halloween Tumbler Reseller Black Magic

Feed

By RC Staff

19 September 2026

Key Points

The Black Magic 40 oz Quencher retailed for $50 and sold out first among six new Halloween pieces
Black Magic 40 oz tumblers are now reselling for up to $120 on eBay
Tumblers may still be on shelves at Dick’s Sporting Goods locations after online stock sold out

Stanley went full gothic for this year’s Halloween drop, and one design didn’t even make it a full day at retail. The brand launched two new colorways, Bordeaux Lace and a black-and-gold Black Magic, across tumblers, mugs and flasks yesterday. Skip the cartoon pumpkins, this collection is built around lace, moths and potion bottles instead. Black Magic’s flagship 40 oz Quencher was the first piece to go, and it’s already popping up on the resale market for more than double what people paid for it at checkout.

Stanley Black Magic and Bordeaux Lace Tumblers

Stanley’s Halloween collection page is showing the Black Magic 40 oz as sold out, but Bordeaux Lace and the smaller Black Magic sizes, like the 20 oz Quencher and the 16 oz Everyday Tumbler, are worth checking too since they share the same artwork.

Stanley Black Magic Bordeaux Lace Halloween

Dick’s Sporting Goods carries Stanley’s drinkware lineup in stores, and Black Magic 40 oz units may still be sitting on shelves there since most resellers were watching stanley1913.com directly. Worth a quick call to your local store before you drive out.

Stanley Halloween Tumblers Resell

Black Magic 40 oz tumblers have already sold for up to $120, which puts you at a solid profit even after eBay’s fees and shipping. Stanley cups don’t move the way they did a couple years ago, but a piece that sells out same-day at retail is a decent signal this one has real demand behind it rather than just brand recognition carrying it.

If you’re buying direct from a retailer like Dick’s, their standard return policy should still apply, so keep the receipt just in case demand cools before you list it.

Halloween drops have a short shelf life by nature. Once the season winds down, so does the resale demand for anything tied to it.