Lil Peep's Castles Anniversary Vinyl Flips for Up to $250

Most vinyl resellers missed this drop

Lil Peep Castles Anniversary Vinyl Reseller
News

By RC Staff

Key Points

  • Lil Peep’s Castles I & II 10 Year Anniversary 2LP Pop Up Edition retailed for $75 and sold out fast

  • The numbered pop up vinyl now resells for $200 to $250 across the secondary market

  • Just 3,500 individually numbered copies were made with a folding pop up castle jacket

Ten years after Lil Peep and Lil Tracy first dropped Castles, the anniversary reissue came and went almost without warning. The Estate of Gustav Ahr’s pop-up 2LP undercut typical premium vinyl box pricing while still delivering the kind of packaging Peep collectors line up for: foil numbered copies, a fold-out castle jacket, and custom pressed discs. Resellers who caught it before it disappeared are now sitting on a flip that’s tripling their money, proof that even a niche mixtape anniversary can move on the secondary market when the packaging does the talking.

Lil Peep Castles I & II Anniversary Vinyl

Castles is a three-track EP Lil Peep and Lil Tracy recorded together in Los Angeles in late June 2016, just weeks after the two met and started living together. It came out July 4, 2016, and Castles II followed that February with five more tracks, including fan favorites like “Witchblades” and “White Wine.” Those two projects have become deep cuts that longtime fans hold up over the bigger commercial releases.

To mark ten years since the original drop, the Estate of Gustav Ahr put out a proper collector’s edition instead of just repressing the same record. The 10 Year Anniversary 2LP Pop Up Edition is cut at 45rpm across a triple pocket gatefold jacket, with two 3D castle pop-ups built into the packaging and custom UV printed, castle themed discs.

Tracy Lil Peep Castles Anniversary Vinyl

Every copy is individually foil numbered, and the whole run was capped at 3,500. This isn’t the $24.98 splatter reissue that’s still sitting in the Castles collection online. It’s the premium version, and it sold out fast enough that the product page now just says “sold out” with no price listed.

Castles I & II Anniversary Vinyl Resells

With the retail run gone, resellers are seeing this one move for $200 to $250 depending on the numbering and condition, more than double what it cost at retail. That’s a strong return for a vinyl flip, especially one that most people weren’t watching closely before it dropped.

Lil Peep Castles Anniversary Vinyl for Sale

Buy in at $75 and sell at the middle of that range, say $225, and after standard eBay fees of 13.6 percent you’re still clearing roughly $195 in profit per copy, assuming you can source it near retail on the resale market itself.

A print run of 3,500 individually numbered copies is small for an artist with Peep’s collector base, and the packaging gives this one a tactile, gift-worthy quality that plain repress vinyl doesn’t have. Anniversary editions tied to Peep’s catalog tend to carry extra weight with fans, and a numbered, limited object like this reads more like a keepsake than a standard record store pickup. Combine that with a release that a lot of collectors and resellers simply weren’t tracking, and you get a sellout that outpaced expectations before the market caught up.

Bottom Line

This was a simple, straight-up vinyl flip that’s trading for up to three times the sticker price. Strictly limited quantities and built-in nostalgia combined to make this a lucrative flip for resellers, especially considering how many of Lil Peep’s fans completely missed this drop.

Get posts like these in your inbox.

Monthly digest of the best of Resell Calendar.

Related Articles

Xbox 25th Anniversary Console X25 Reseller
News

Consoles

Xbox Confirms Restock for Sold Out X25 Anniversary Consoles

These are reselling for over $1,500

Starbucks Bearista Cup Mystery Box 2026
News

Home & Living

Starbucks Bearista Surprise Boxes are a Great Flip

Resellers took home hundreds in profit

Ocarina Time Remake Retailer Display Reseller
News

Art & Collectibles

Ocarina of Time's Cardboard Retailer Displays are Selling on eBay

These, uh, aren't for sale

Selfridges GTA 6 Cheetah For Sale
News

Cars

Selfridges' GTA 6 Pop-Up Includes a Drivable Supercar

Remember when Rockstar used to give stuff away?

NeeDoh Lava Lamp Target Reseller Collector
News

Toys & Games

NeeDoh Lava Lamps Resell for Over $250 on eBay

Check your local Target for stock

GTA 6 Festival Ticket Reseller Details
News

Music & Movies

GTA 6 Festival Tickets: Pricing, Resale Policy, and More

You must enter the lottery by tomorrow

ModRetro OpenAI Chromatic DevDay Restock Reseller
News

Gadgets & Electronics

ModRetro X OpenAI Codex Edition Chromatic Is Live

But don't rush to buy

Selfridges GTA 6 Merch UK Reseller
News

Clothing & Accessories

Selfridges' GTA 6 Merch Collection: Here's What We Know

Limited edition GTA 6 has been lucrative for resellers

US Mint Gold Trump Coin Reseller
News

Coins

Trump's 24K Gold Coin Drops November 19

These will be $5,000+

Start Here

How to Resell Toys Guide Flipping
How to Resell Toys for a Profit

This is one of the most volatile markets for resellers

eBay Item Not Selling Guide for Resellers
What to Do When Your eBay Listing isn't Selling

Unfortunately, it will happen to every reseller

Beginners Guide to Reselling Flipping 2026
How to Start Reselling in 2026: A Complete Beginner's Guide

From total noob to seasoned pro, we're here to answer all your questions

Pounce on resell opportunities before they sell out.

Get the details

How to Resell Toys Guide Flipping
How to Resell Toys for a Profit

This is one of the most volatile markets for resellers

eBay Item Not Selling Guide for Resellers
What to Do When Your eBay Listing isn't Selling

Unfortunately, it will happen to every reseller

Beginners Guide to Reselling Flipping 2026
How to Start Reselling in 2026: A Complete Beginner's Guide

From total noob to seasoned pro, we're here to answer all your questions

Subscribe to Newsletter

A monthly digest of the best of Resell Calendar.